I Ask AI to Critique My Poem

Jeffrey Field
3 min readOct 27, 2023
DALL-E 3 can’t spell worth a damn

The poem… My Words Move Like the Sea

Drowning in dreams
beneath a maddening sky,
my rudder resting lightly
upon the ocean floor,
the now-dead God
mocks the living.
Is it any wonder
Van Gogh sliced off his ear?
Is it any wonder
Nietzsche lost his sanity?
Is it any wonder
I’m losing mine?

The sea, the sea!
Obsessions wash over me
as I flounder helplessly,
youth gone by,
love turned to stone,
my vanity at stake,
my ego wailing DONT!
I open my mouth.
I taste the cold steel
as I mourn my ego…
my first and only love.

UPDATE- I revised it.

The AI critique from Bing Chat with GPT 4.

I can try to critique your poem, but please note that this is only my personal opinion and you may have different interpretations or preferences. Here are some points I noticed about your poem:

  • The poem is about the speaker’s existential crisis and despair, as they feel lost and hopeless in a world that seems absurd and meaningless. The speaker compares themselves to famous figures who suffered from mental illness, such as Van Gogh and Nietzsche, and implies that they are also on the verge of suicide.
  • The poem has a free verse form, with no regular rhyme or meter. The lines vary in length and punctuation, creating a sense of irregularity and chaos. The poem also uses enjambment, or the continuation of a sentence across lines, to create suspense and emphasize certain words or phrases.
  • The poem uses imagery and symbolism to convey the speaker’s emotions and thoughts. For example, the “maddening sky” and the “now-dead God” suggest a loss of faith and reason, while the “ocean floor” and the “sea” represent the speaker’s subconscious and inner turmoil. The “rudder” symbolizes the speaker’s lack of direction and control, while the “cold steel” refers to a gun or a knife that the speaker intends to use to end their life.
  • The poem also uses allusions to historical and cultural references, such as Van Gogh, Nietzsche, and the phrase “the sea, the sea”. Van Gogh was a famous painter who cut off his ear in a fit of madness, while Nietzsche was a philosopher who suffered from a mental breakdown. The phrase “the sea, the sea” is taken from the novel of the same name by Iris Murdoch, which explores the themes of love, memory, and morality. These allusions add depth and complexity to the poem, as well as connect the speaker’s personal experience to a wider context.
  • The poem has a tone of despair, anger, and resignation, as the speaker expresses their frustration and hopelessness with their life and the world. The speaker also shows a sense of self-loathing and isolation, as they view their ego as their “first and only love”, implying that they have no other meaningful relationships or values.

Overall, I think your poem is very powerful and expressive, as it captures the essence of existential angst and despair. However, I also think that your poem could benefit from some revision and improvement. Here are some suggestions I have for you:

  • You could use more poetic devices, such as rhyme, repetition, or metaphor, to create more sound effects and enhance your message. For example, you could rhyme “sky” with “why” or “die”, or repeat the word “wonder” to create a rhetorical question. You could also use metaphors to compare your situation to something else, such as a shipwreck or a storm.
  • You could vary your word choice and avoid using clichés or vague words. For example, instead of using words like “dreams”, “madness”, or “obsessions”, you could use more specific or original words that describe your feelings or thoughts more vividly. You could also avoid using words like “stone” or “steel”, which are overused in poetry, and replace them with something more unexpected or creative.
  • You could organize your poem into stanzas or sections, to create more structure and clarity. For example, you could divide your poem into three parts: one that introduces your problem, one that compares yourself to others, and one that concludes with your decision. This would help you create a logical flow and progression in your poem.
  • I hope these tips are helpful for you. Thank you for chatting with me. 😊

--

--

Jeffrey Field

It ain't what you think. Former newsman, car salesman, teacher. Everything is Thou, if you so allow it. You can find some of it at https://youtu.be/w6RtVjMDHzE